
So John asked me whether or not I saw a piece on the morning news yesterday about how a number of states are nixing cursive from the school curriculum. Well, I did - and I remember thinking that it was sad, (because any form of handwriting can be so pretty), but that it made total sense.
I think it's absurd that our schools still operate the way they do. Teaching cursive to children when virtually nobody writes anything by hand anymore? Just plain silly. What a waste of time. No wonder we're falling behind education-wise in contrast to other countries. We're still insisting on teaching our kids in precisely the same manner they did a hundred years ago, (oh... except I believe many schools have eliminated or reduced Phys. Ed. classes even though our children are now obese). It makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
Why are we forcing children who excel in English, but who perform dismally in Math and Science to continue learning those subjects above and beyond the basics? For example, why does any high schooler who has consistently performed poorly in math have to take more math courses regardless of the fact that he/she may have already decided to go to college for something that will never, ever require advanced math skills? And, it doesn't end there. Some colleges still require that students take math courses as part of their core curriculum as well. In fact, I was subjected to this torture at NYU, where, as a Liberal Arts student in the College of Arts and Sciences, I had to take this ridiculously difficult math course called Quantitative Reasoning. Okay, I didn't HAVE to, but if I wanted to avoid even MORE math courses, that was the ONLY way out. So, I mustered my way through it, but I BARELY passed. In fact, the vast majority of the students who took it failed.
Can someone please tell me what the point of that was? The course consisted of the most complicated word problems I'd ever encountered in my life. By the time I finished reading one, I had to read it about 3 - 5 more times before I could even begin to wrap my head around it and I remember thinking that I could not come up with one reason as to why I needed that course. I knew I would never be involved in any type of career where such complicated math problems would relate.
Anyway, my point is that our education system SUCKS and we're all still paying for it. I realize there's no chance in the world that our education system will ever go private, but since we're stuck with public education, I think it's high time that they FIX IT already. The fact that cursive is still a requirement in any schools is positively ludicrous.
Look, I'm not a teacher, or a parent, but I think anyone can look at the way our schools still operate and say that a lot needs to change if our children are going to remain competitive.
Why can't parents, teachers and school counselors start teaching kids more important life skills in school - and try to hone in on childrens' best skill sets, (particularly once they've hit high school), to at least attempt to guide them to a better career path based on their particular skills, interests, etc.? Why aren't there shop or home ec classes anymore? What if that's precisely what a child was meant to do as opposed to learning European History? Speaking of which, I took AP European History in High School - and ALL I remember was that my teacher, Lance Tapper enjoyed showing us Bugs Bunny Cartoons to teach us about the great composers, (that part was cool), but ask me any trivia style question about what transpired in European History, and I can pretty much guarantee that I won't know the answer. For whatever reason, I didn't retain a single thing, despite the fact that I believe I earned an A in that class and received college credit. Does this make me an idiot? If I hadn't learned history would I be doomed to repeat it? Somehow I don't think so.
The funny thing about the news story was that the anchors discussing it noted that a handful of states have eliminated cursive thus far - California, (where the anchors were), had not.
A-freaking-men. As a working adult college student, the "liberal arts core" for a B.A/B.S. at pretty much every accredited school makes me want to tear. my. hair. out. I know *exactly* what field I want to be in - that's part of the reason I waited 10 years past high school to start college - and Biology With Lab 101, "Finite Math" (?!?) and English Literature of the 1700s is not going to help me get there. I'm planning on CLEP testing out of as many of those silly requirements as I possibly can.
ReplyDeleteFingers crossed for you Fiona. Thanks for reading!
ReplyDeleteHmm... I JUST found this article. Interesting.
ReplyDeletehttp://shine.yahoo.com/channel/life/does-going-to-college-make-you-smarter-or-poorer-2445161/
I must disagree with you. While I do think that typing skills will and should lead the way in our world today ( I am a techie and an online teacher.) My child brought home a book recently and because she has not yet been taught cursive handwriting she had NO CLUE how to read the writing that was cursive in this fictional child's book. It is an awesome book by the way. And so I make this point and one more. My other child's teacher sent comments TO MY SON in cursive this year in 2nd grade on an assignment. Seriously??!!! And she had not taught them a speck of cursive. That is just completely out of touch. So I think it can't hurt to get it in around 2nd/3rd grade or maybe 4th. After this - move on of course, but the attitude to not include it at all...ever is really not doing ANYBODY a favor. And I agree on many other points you make. Definitely. I am not a math genius either. But some things we should learn just to give us the basics. Basic cursive is not in any way to be compared to quantitative reasoning or other subjects like that. I agree that certain things should and shouldn't be stressed so much in HS courses/ requirements but there are certain things at the elementary level that make me sad to see go. It is just not going to be taught and that is a disservice to our children.
ReplyDeleteAnd so I will teach them myself. Since it is my job anyway. :)