Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Discipline
















It seems parents have literally gotten to the point where they're afraid to discipline their children. I'm not talking about hitting, spanking or any form of physical discipline, (in fact I tend to not agree with that at all). I'm talking about what parents do when their children are literally being crazed, spoiled, tantrum-throwing little maniacs, (as kids tend to be from time-to-time), and how they opt to deal with it.

Here's a case in-point. John drew this illustration of a child he just saw in the Ralph's supermarket on our block. This girl, while cute, had turned into a bit of a demonic nightmare, as she plopped herself down in the center of a grocery aisle, and basically started screeching at the top of her lungs for some reason or another. (Chances are, she was just a bit cranky and/or not getting her way in some manner).

That said, the Mother attempted to address her daughter as follows:

"My goodness. You're in a bad mood. Please stop that. Please, please, please stop that" in a voice that was barely above a whisper.

Needless to say, it didn't work.

I don't know what this business is of begging and pleading with your children to listen to you as its parent and guide. You shouldn't have to ask a shrieking child to, "...please stop doing that." You should simply be able to say, in a stern, direct manner - "I am not going to tolerate that kind of behavior from you, and if it continues, there will be consequences."

Albeit, that language might be a bit too elevated for a toddler, but you get my drift.

And, on another note, maybe that language isn't too elevated. Kids are sponges and I feel like they're treated like morons.

But that's another post.

Correct me if I'm wrong - but this soft-spoken business, when dealing with a child who is clearly not a moron and who is clearly manipulating its parent because it knows it can, is absurd.

Look, I know many parents out there might come after me for this - because I've never been there - and I'm sure there is a bit of desperation on the part of the parent - particularly when in public - but I guess what I'm getting at, is that too many parents want to be their children's friends - and not disciplinarians, even when it's in the best interest of the child.

And look - I've seen the opposite end of the spectrum as well - unnecessarily harsh discipline that doesn't really seem to do much other than hurt - but again, this sweet, begging/pleading stuff is just nauseating.

We all have to learn our lessons - both as kids and as adults. And look, I'm more than willing to admit that I have absolutely NO IDEA whether or not I could effectively discipline a crazed maniacal little toddler... but I'm pretty confident that I wouldn't say please in a voice that smacks of Cartman's Mom on South Park. "Poopsykins" anyone?

Alright, we're open for comments folks.

Oh - and my sincerest thanks to my hubby John for the AWESOME illustration. Love, love, love.

2 comments:

  1. Whispering *can* have its place... I mean, I've used it to get the attention of a screaming toddler, because sometimes, it gets them curious, and they shut up for a second, to hear me whispering things like, "Kid, if you do not cut.this.out.right.now there will be hell to pay."

    I agree with you... Parents are too soft oftentimes. I'm not hanging around my kids to be their friend.

    And, nope, I don't think saying things like, "There will be consequences!" is above a kids head. It drives me nuts when people treat kids like they're dumb... They're not. Promise!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Okay - the whispering thing... totally on board. I don't really enjoy yelling either... And the way you described the manner with which you use it, (whispering that is), totally legitimizes it as a badass parenting tool. Got it. It's the begging and pleading AND the whispering and basically pussy-footing around bratty kids that I can't stand, (which I'm pretty sure you don't do).

    ReplyDelete